The Value of Advice

Advice is both vital and a bane.


Author Photo

Written by Suresh Sadagopan

Author Photo

Vital when getting the direction or decision right is critical. This is when good advisors can really make a difference. Such advisors will need to be knowledgeable, have expertise in the domain and should have the best interests of those who they are advising. They need to have high levels of ethics, integrity and be fully trust-worthy.


What many find are advisors who are offering their two-cents that are worth far less! The only problem is that people think that such advisors are worth their weight in Gold. That is the irony. Influencers present content with click-bait headlines that lures people by the lakhs.


Then there are product pushers masquerading as advisors, push their products and play the yes man role to get custom. Unfortunately, investors love such advisors who suggest fresh products, are flexible and accommodate the investor's penchant for variety and return fixation. Many of them are big, recognisable names!


Financial Advisors and what they should do - True advisors need to engage with their clients and work purely in their best interests. They need to be Fiduciaries. For this, they need to stay away from conflicts of interest, be independent, unbiased and offer advice after fully understanding their client's position. Finding a fiduciary means you have found a confidante, who ensures that money is managed well, goals and expenses are met, wealth creation ensues and life itself is sorted


This is the difficult part today. You find advisors in the form of doctors, lawyers, architects, etc. in their respective fields. Finding a client centric fiduciary advisor is a mirage today - for there are just about 300 active in India, who are around to offer real advice! If you are one of them, you are so much ahead in the game.


Money management - A Fiduciary advisor helps in efficient money management. This is done through appropriate investments to take care of goals, liquidity, contingency and wealth creation in an efficient manner. Investments are made based on Asset allocation principles, according to the personal situation in life, risk profile and other factors.


Also, a good advisor always looks at the costs the clients are incurring. Firstly, the investments are suggested in commission-free products, lowering costs.


Secondly, the move is towards simplicity in the products suggested, resulting in better alignment and fit. Also, simple products tend to be lower in costs compared to complex products that are costly and mostly do no better than the simple ones.


Thirdly, only a Fiduciary will suggest passive products, which distributor, wealth manager etc. will not suggest. These products are very low in terms of cost and offer better returns.


Avoiding Mistakes - In the absence of a good advisor, investors tend to be led astray and make mistakes and even blunders, which set them back by years and in money terms, inhibits their portfolio growth by a huge factor. An example of this would be inappropriate insurance which offers low returns and is misaligned to their situation. Other examples are investing in land and properties, speculative assets, doing day trading etc.


We have seen that some of these indicretions can be disastrous and have a huge adverse impact on their portfolio performance and the usefulness of these products in their life.


Financial advice when it is needed - As we go along in life, there are several points where Financial counsel is necessary. Most people do not have an advisor and ask their friends, read up articles and blogs and ask their expert friends for advice. This kind of advice is like one blind person leading another, resulting in a mess-up in the portfolio, goal achievement and life.


A good financial advisor who knows the real position of the client will be able to offer tailored advice that is in their best interests, in every respect. Having a financial advisor to consult at every point is very important and saves one from the blushes and helps one take the right decisions.


Returns of the portfolio - One should not go to a financial advisor to get better returns. Rather the Financial Advisor ensures that there is a good plan to follow, have a guide along the way, goals are met, wealth gets created, right decisions are taken along the way etc.


Hence, the value of the advisor cannot be reduced to just investment returns.


And yet, even there a good advisor would score. See this table -


Fund/ Index returns

As on Nov 30, 2025 Value of the invested amount in
MF Scheme Inv Amount 7 years 5 years 3 years
ICICI Pru Bluechip Fund(G) 10,000 30,277 25,236 16,476
Nippon India Large Cap Fund(G) 10,000 30,485 28,287 17,020
ICICI Pru Large & Mid Cap Fund(G) 10,000 36,031 31,292 18,022
HDFC Large and Mid Cap Fund(G) 10,000 34,262 29,690 17,477
HDFC Flexi Cap Fund(G) 10,000 35,297 32,476 17,968
Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund(G) 10,000 39,307 26,737 18,078
Nippon India Growth Fund(G) 10,000 43,040 33,491 19,707
HDFC Mid-Cap Opportunities Fund(G) 10,000 41,209 33,798 20,108
NIFTY Large Midcap 250 TRI 10,000 31,741 25,814 16,633
NIFTY 100 TRI 10,000 26,089 21,368 14,586
NIFTY 500 TRI 10,000 28,278 23,238 15,433
NIFTY Midcap 150 TRI 10,000 38,125 30,838 18,828
Value of the Funds 80,000 2,89,908 2,41,007 1,44,856
Value of the Index 80,000 2,48,466 2,02,516 1,30,960
Fund returns % 20.19% 24.68% 21.88%
Index return % 17.57% 20.41% 17.86%
Returns of the Fund over Index pa 2.62% 4.26% 4.03%

In the above table you would observe that if you would have invested in the schemes coming as per our MF Rationale, the excess returns of the scheme over the corresponding Index would have been 2.62% pa in the 7 year period and 4.26% pa in the 5 year period.


Smooth Baton Exchange - This is probably the most important one of all. When it comes to Succession after ones lifetime, it happens very smoothly considering that the advisor knows all about the assets, why they have been invested and would smoothly take over and assist the next of kin in a smooth transition.


Conclusion - Valuing the advice is a difficult proposition. Putting a money or a percentage of Assets value is difficult for any of the above assists by the advisor ( except for the return excess of schemes over the index ).


However, if one were to put even 0.5% -1% as the value of the advisor for each one of the advisory assists ( not counting the excess returns that I had shown in the table earlier ) I have mentioned, the value of that alone would be between 2.5%- 5% pa. Now it is debatable what value we should attach to each one. But whatever value one attaches, it would be more than what we charge which is less than one percent pa.


We are counting the blessings in having you as our client. Considering the symbiotic relationship we enjoy, so should you ??



L

A

D

I

N

G

.

.

.